There Are No “Bad Apples”, Just An Organized Gang of Rotten NYPD Thugs

Eric and wife Esaw Garner
Eric and wife Esaw Garner

“When I kissed my husband this morning, I never thought it would be for the last time,” says the wife of 43 year-old Eric Garner, whose videotaped death at the hands of New York Police on Staten Island last Thursday is causing outrage among members of the local community and spreading throughout the nation at-large. Though the incident happened shortly after 5:00 P.M., Esaw wasn’t notified until much later at night when she was called to come to the hospital to identify her loved one’s body. When she arrived in the paramedic’s room and saw Eric Garner’s body, she began speaking to him, hoping to God he wasn’t yet gone. “I saw him with his eyes wide open and I said, ‘Babe, don’t leave me, I need you.’ But he was already gone.” Afterword, she confronted the police officers and asked them to explain what had happened to her, but they greeted her with indifference. Now, having seen how the entire scene played out on video, Mrs. Garner believes she knows why. “They’re covering their asses,” she explained. “They harassed and harassed my husband until they killed him.”

Everyone who witnessed the scene, aside from the police officers, unanimously stated that Eric Garner was on the sidewalk in front of the Bay Street Beauty Shop that day because he was breaking up a fight. When two plainclothes and completely unwarranted police officers arrived on the scene, however, they immediately began accusing Garner of illegally selling “un-taxed cigarettes.”  (You’ve got to be kidding me!) (*) Mr. Garner and and his friend Ramsey Orta, the 22 year-old who captured it all on video, informed the officers that all he did was break up a fight and was not selling loose cigarettes to anybody. But the NYPD officers showed little regard for the truth, and insisted that Garner was a liar. This isn’t the first time he’s been harassed by New York police however. After all, it is an organization which dedicates itself to making the lives of African American men and women unbearable by constantly subjecting them to the most humiliating “stop-and-frisk” searches without any cause whatsoever. (These searches, conducted almost exclusively on Black and Latino men, rarely yield anything to begin with.) “I didn’t do shit! I was just minding my own business. Just leave me alone,” says Garner to the invasive police, one of whom poses with his arms folded, looking like the huge peckerwood he is. That officer is Daniel Pantaleo, who apparently has a history of targeting and harassing Black men, in addition to falsifying reports in order to have them thrown in jail. In two previous cases, Pantaleo took pleasure in ordering Black men to “pull their pants and underwear down; squat and cough” in the street. Taking this into account, it is entirely justified that Eric Garner expressed his frustration by saying, “Every time you see me you want to mess with me. I’m tired of it. It stops today!” That is when things took a violent turn for the worse.

The Garner Family
The Garner Family

The racist peckerwood cop Daniel Pantaleo jumps Eric Garner from behind.
The racist peckerwood cop Daniel Pantaleo jumps Eric Garner from behind.

The police officers apparently felt that Garner’s voicing his displeasure with their intrusiveness was grounds for an arrest (more like a scheme to collect more bail money). As the first cop moved in with the handcuffs, a frustrated Garner pulled his hands away (not toward) the cop and pleaded, “Don’t touch me, please.” Daniel Peckerwood Pantaleo then sneak attacked Mr. Garner from behind, wrapping his arms around Garner’s neck and placing him in a choke-hold before violently slamming his head into the ground. By this time there are at least seven officers on the scene and all of them are assisting in attacking this one man. (The only other of these officers whose name has been revealed to the press is that of Justin Damico.) A witness to these events, 36 year-old Taisha Allen recalls how Pantaleo had “his knee on Mr. Garner’s back and was ordering him to put his hands behind his back”, all this while still slamming Garner’s head into the sidewalk and pressing his neck down with all the might he had. That the disgraced officer was cutting off Garner’s ventilation should’ve been obvious to everyone there. It was impossible for them not to hear as he desperately cried out a total of eleven times: “I can’t breathe! I can’t breathe! I can’t breathe! I cant’ breathe! I can’t breathe! I can’t breathe…” Yet not a single one of the 7-8 officers who helped restrain him apparently thought his life worthy of protecting. Instead of seeing him as the adored father of six children with two newly-arrived grandchildren that he was, they saw only his brown skin.

article-choke4-0717And so it should come as no surprise that not one member of this gang of police officers gave the slightest indication of having a care in the world as Eric Garner went unconscious. In fact some of them were far more concerned with blocking Ramsey Orta’s camera from catching the incident on tape, pressing themselves in front of the bystander and repeatedly yelling at him to “back up!” It also appears that the paramedics weren’t even called to the scene until after Garner was already dead. As the paramedics arrived, they do nothing to try and breathe life back into this now lifeless body. In fact, they act as if this was no emergency at all, as if to say, “Oh well. Another one bites the dust.” That is when one concerned bystander called out, “Why is no one doing CPR?!” The officers replied by insisting that it would be unnecessary because Garner is still breathing. (These people are professional liars.) Of course they had plenty of time to go through their victim’s pockets, however, confiscating his cellphone and “untaxed” cigarettes. Elsewhere Daniel Peckerwood Pantaleo can be seen chatting it up with his officer buddies, showing not a bit of remorse or concern for having just killed a man. At one point he is even be seen waving sarcastically at Orta’s camera, knowing full well his superiors have no intention of holding him accountable for his actions.

Meanwhile the police report filed shortly after the incident made absolutely no mention of Pantaleo’s holding Garner in a chokehold! It included testimony from such liars as Sgt. Dhanan Saminath, who described what they were doing to Garner as “maintaining control of him” and claimed that he “did not appear to be in great distress.” Sgt. Kizzy Adonis followed that up by saying that Garner, whom she outrageously and disrespectfully referred to as “the perpetrator”, seemed to be in an okay condition which “did not appear to get worse.”

Daniel "Peckerwood" Pantaleo
Daniel “Peckerwood” Pantaleo who was seen strangling Eric Garner to death.

The NYPD has responded to the outrage surrounding the video by announcing its intention to conduct an “internal affairs investigation”, which is really just code for doing as little as possible. Rarely does a department bring charges against one of its own, and when it does it’s always at a minimal in order to make it appear to the public like a fair and impartial investigation was conducted. Pantaleo, I suspect, will be the only officer charged with something like “accidental homicide”, and you can be certain that the system will try to have him tried wherever he’s most likely to get an all-white jury. Currently Pantaleo has been assigned to desk duty while the “investigation” is underway. He is still going to get the same amount of pay, but apparently reassigning him temporarily to work at a desk job was a step to far for New York’s most prominent police union, the Patrolmen’s Benevolent Association, which called even this minimal action “completely unwarranted.” Though a law was passed in 1993 expressly forbidding police officers from placing someone in a choke-hold, there have been at least 1,000 chokehold complaints against NYPD officers since 2009, though less than ten resulted in any kind of action being taken. Just three days prior to Garner’s murder, cops violently assaulted Ronalds Johns in a Harlem Subway station, pepper-spraying him in the face while holding him in a chokehold.

Esaw Garner (center) mourns the death of her spouse Eric Garner at the hands of the NYPD. National Action Network leader Al Sharpton is pictured at right.
Esaw Garner (center) mourns the death of her spouse Eric Garner at the hands of the NYPD. National Action Network leader Al Sharpton is pictured at right.

Perhaps no one is more devastated by the loss of Eric Garner than the woman who brought him into the world 43 years ago, his 65 year-old mother Gwen Carr. As painful as it was for her to watch what those cops did to her son, she is at least thankful that it was captured on video. “I don’t want him to have died in vain,” explained Carr. “As people see, it’s just a godsend that we have the video. Just look at the tape.” She wants to see the officers locked up “just as they would had given my son if the shoe was on the other foot… It’s just a lack of humanity. That’s what it was. He was nothing to them, but he was our people. He was just a big guy on the street.”

The New York City Police Department seeks to make life so oppressive for Black males that they are not even safe from police violence in their own homes. Barely two months ago NYPD officers in the Bronx appear to have falsified a police report in order to justify brutally beating and arresting 19 year-old Jateik Reed, who they claimed was carrying “bags of crack and marijuana”, though there are no bags present in the video from the scene. Their report also claimed he was “resisting an arrest as well as striking an officer”. They of course made no mention of the fact that they were the brutal thugs attempting to beat the living daylights out of Reed with their batons, and furthermore threatened bystanders who were filming the attack.

This is the true face of the NYPD: an organized mob of the most violent people on earth.


* As his sister Ellisha Flagg said later, “Many people that own stores sell illegal cigarettes. They lose their license, not their lives.”

Further Reading:



Protesters Demand Justice For Eric Garner
Protesters Demand Justice For Eric Garner

29 thoughts

  1. At the beginning of the day someone clean should represent a needless loss of life. This is a perfect example of why. If your stepping into a spotlight especially with officials of the city and law enforcement, you shouldn’t have any outstanding crap. You tape them and they tape you. Cameras and quick recognition techniques make a good reason turn ugly real fast.

    So is the answer, ‘Let’s just wait for the next one’? or ‘Should we look into the mirror first’. say to yourself, am I ready, am I the one for the job, Don’t waste this poor mans life on needless aggravation of justice. Your holding yourself’s back and the police are helping you with a smile.

    Be true today.

  2. At times the best medicine is the preventative type. Just in case of another incident like this.

    How many times has anyone had handcuffs on? In the back of a police car. What about gone to jail? Really, tell me the truth. Never once have I been roughed up. I likely have 7 pages. Never charged. But have a life time record that says’s I’m a good father. I give this information freely.

    It is kind of sad to a favorite police story.

    So what happened at the beginning. We shall see. An agitated individual can take up too 5 officers to take them down. They have different levels of dealing with people and suspects. What I see at the last photo is Garner with hand cuffs on and a police officer still with a choke hold.

    A study should be created then implemented. A Florida department could do this investigation.

    1. I think there should be a citizen investigation myself with members from the community without police pressure, coercion or intimidation (if possible). I don’t know how things are in Canada, but I promise you that the police departments are absolutely out of control and refuse to hold each other accountable here in the States. And it’s getting progressively worse.

      1. It only takes one law to start change. It maybe a little hell getting there so the pressure must be kept up. We need a politician, a good solid one..

        1. I understand what you are saying, but the police are literally breaking the laws written in the books already and no politician or law person is willing to hold them to account because the police are serving the interest of the wealthiest of the wealthy capitalists.

  3. I agree with an investigation. In Canada, a separate police department does just that. To ensure the quality of the investigation with an impartial attitude.

    I have said this before, there must be something someone could do, not too be a threat to the officers. Remaining quiet is one until its time to speak. If they up say, ‘against the wall’, do it immediately. For every action there is a reaction in very case.

    1. I have to strongly disagree with you. People here are tired of being forced to comply and sit quietly as they are violated and discriminated against. I respect anyone’s decision to comply if it makes them feel safer. However, those who choose to resist the humiliation of being harassed by police everywhere they go deserve much praise in my book. The only way change, real authentic change, ever occurs is by persistent resistance. An oppressive system has never been done away with by simply complying with each request by the authorities.

      1. I’m OK with the disagreement. However I hope people are not leaving their homes to die by cop. If your part of the demonstration your taking your chances. But what I mean is, ‘What if your walking by’ and become an unwilling participant..

        1. I’m not sure exactly what you mean. You mean like if you just so happen to be walking down the street and you see that a cop is messing with somebody? Or do you mean like if a cop just starts messing with you? I mean, I’m not saying I think people should go out and try to get killed by cops. Far from it! I just believe that whoever is getting harassed by cops should have the right to either be safe and go along or to resist if they so choose. Of course the latter could quite possibly have a very dangerous outcome, but my point is mainly that it is still the cop who is needlessly harassing someone who is at fault, and not the person who resisted an unjust arrest.

          1. Morning Caleb. Understand me please I come from Canada. Police, police themselves quite well and are subjected too coarse evaluations to their conduct. There is a pride thing about being a police officer here. At one point many years ago the same was happening in all of the provinces and cities of Canada. Police brutality was common and any infractions were investigated by the same department itself. Now it is done by a different city police department instead.

            So the Eric Garner case is a good time to start this new policing investigations practice..

            “”””but my point is mainly that it is still the cop who is needlessly harassing someone who is at fault, and not the person who resisted an unjust arrest””

            If you make yourself a target, what do you think will happen? I am, ‘for’ this case.

            1. Perhaps police in Canada actually do function in a way that doesn’t try to catch ppl up in the system, but the thing about “if you make yourself a target, what do you think will happen” kind of misses my point, because police are essentially designating people in certain communities as targets and so an angry reaction to being constantly made a target it is only natural.

              1. Well actually yes they do, they like to catch bad guys and those showing potential. Most minor incidents of conduct and punishments are generally run within the departments, the serious is moved to another city then investigated.

  4. Caleb, Thank you for the follow up and new information. It is impossible for any one person to keep up with the #injustices of #policebrutality and harassment. It is also emotionally draining and depressing, however, you are an inspiration to continue the fight. Thank you once again.

    I reblogged.

    1. I share your sentiments on this Angela. I can’t even keep track of all the many cases of police racism, abuse and terrorizing of whole communities because there are so many, and after awhile I find myself coming across stories and adding them to “read later” list or “watch later” in cases of video, because it can be rather enraging and/or depressing to dwell on these stories. Many would like to tune the reality of police cruelty out entirely because they don’t want to deal or are unable to cope with living in such a repressive environment, especially after having been told since birth that we are in the “most free and just democracy the world has ever known.”

      1. Caleb, do you get threats? The police are all over the internet. They know our sites, and they play dirty.

        I imagine some of the flack I get on youtube are from trashy people and includes them. Have heard that sites like ours get targeted with overwhelming threats.

        1. I suspect if they were aware of mine (I have no way if knowing if they are or not) I would likely be getting harassed. I haven’t received too many just yet. I’ve had some comments in which victims were blamed for an attack by police that I replied to and received no answer back. And I’ve also been “followed” on Twitter by some police department in Florida one time, I believe it was Miami-Dade?? But I’m not sure anymore it was awhile back and I immediately blocked it.

  5. If the first set of officers had just walked away after Eric Garner told them he wasn’t doing anything wrong, none of this would have happened and he’d still be alive. There was clearly no reason for the police to even continue to talk to him, much less hold him down and choke him.

    Thanks for drawing attention to this issue. Police brutality is still a problem and needs to stop.

    1. Agreed. I mean it was pretty obvious that no one around Garner was being in any way threatened by his presence. It just goes to show that the system is set up in a way for officers to go and create trouble in situations where there aren’t any in order to meet their quotas. It certainly isn’t a deterrent for crime.

  6. I am more than appalled at what happened to Eric Garner. And to all those whose skin happens to be black or brown in New York City. There should be a federal investigation outside of the city. With videos showing what happened, surely some justice is forthcoming. This is disgusting that police officers partake in this sort of behavior.

    1. You’re right. And what is important to know is that this case is certainly no anomaly. It happens very often all of this country very frequently, yet only some cases manage to resonate with the public through the media from time to time. There are so many victims whose names we may never know. But I sure hope these officers are held accountable for what they did to Eric Garner. (I won’t hold my breath but I’ll certainly be watching closely.)

Leave a Reply to Angela Grant Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s